2019年12月19日星期四

低稅吸人才,樓價亦得益

載於2019年12月19日信報 :

筆者早於「環球減稅搶飯碗,港府自滿毀長城」一文已點出本港低稅聲譽近年已岌岌可危,大有被各曾是高稅國度迎頭趕上之虞。而當今其中一個最積極減輕人民負擔的政權,正是利商為本的特朗普政府!
下文將檢視美國不同州份在稅率上的競爭,及其對人口流動甚至物業價格之影響。


低企業稅能增加就業

將美國目前各州之最高企業稅率作比較,似可得出以下結論:隨著公司將業務轉移到低稅州份,該地亦可享有更蓬勃的人口增長。

在本文餘下部分,筆者將重點專注幾個較出名的州份:即德州,特拉華,及佛羅里達(皆以較低的稅率聞名),以及加州,紐約,和伊利諾(全以多監管和重企業負擔著稱);此六個州份在隨後的圖表中將以橙色作標示。

在過去十年(2010-2019年),低企業稅率州份,如內華達,華盛頓,南達哥他(【圖一】綠點),都見證了百分之十餘幅度之人口增長;相反,高稅率州份(【圖一】紅點)只錄得單位數增長甚至出現人口下降的現象(如伊利諾):

圖一: 低稅率吸引人才遷入

個人稅負高低 影響人口流向

僅僅降低企業稅負擔應該不夠,因為員工淨收入必影響僱員去留的意欲。因此,筆者亦納入了「居民稅負」這項指標,因其包含了所有州立和地方層面的稅項,如物業稅,所得稅,銷售稅和消費稅等。

一如所料,個人稅負亦對人口增長速度有相同的影響:本文專注之低居民稅負州份再次錄得較高人口增長(特拉華、佛羅里達、德州),而高居民稅負州份(紐約、夏威夷、緬因)則在過去十年中增長欠奉:

圖二: 高居民稅負拖低人口增速


減稅是否有效的刺激增長政策?

那麼哪個州在吸引移民方面做得最成功?與夏威夷和路易士安拿相比,特拉華和佛羅里達(兩者皆是本文專注州份)似乎做得最多,也的確達到了甚佳結果,因十年內居民人數的增長較多:

圖三: 減稅吸引,加稅趕客


行文至此,無論因工作,留學還是退休,有移民打算的人,應可由下圖各州稅負之高低,輕易選取自己的理想目的地矣:


圖四:2019年各州的稅收負擔與2019年全國平均稅收負擔


以上討論中,似乎特拉華和佛羅里達多次「名列前茅」,亦因而應該是大多數要離鄉別井的移民首選之中;相反,身在紐約和夏威夷居民是否應該連繼續留下打拼亦要三思?

移民帶來住屋需求,樓價表現自然出色

對於房地產投資者而言,以上研究的延伸結論,必然是稅負高低影響樓價表現:減稅吸引人流,推高住屋需求,亦因此帶旺樓市。
不出所料,在過去十年中減稅幅度較大的州份(如佛羅里達)樓價上漲幅度最大,而加稅比例最巨者(如路易士安拿和佛蒙特)則樓價升勢溫和得多:

圖五:低稅率似乎也使房價受益

總括而言,投資於低稅率之州份對回報裨益甚大,而投資於正在大幅減稅的地方可能回報更豐。

此一結論,對香港更是當頭棒喝:香港曾經傲視寰宇的低稅率優勢現已逐漸退色,當權者不但不減低人民負擔,更以先掠奪市民收入,繼而施捨彼以「紓困措施」來作「回聵」!當中的道德風險,不可不察。

附圖——將美國各州人口增長及稅負高低合拼以地圖方式顯示:

圖六:高人口增長(深藍色)與大減稅幅度(綠字)結伴同行;反之,低人口增長(淺藍色)與高加稅幅度(紅字)共同進退



筆者特別鳴謝香港城市大學學生梁芊芊協助收集及整理本文相關數據及圖表。

2019年12月18日星期三

Will Macau be the new Hong Kong?

The news that "The central government is planning to develop Macau as financial centre as a contingency back up ...[to] Hong Kong" (link here) has caused more debate on how replaceable HK is as an Asian financial hub.

We have touched on a similar point in a previous post entitled "Will Shenzhen be the new Hong Kong?" where we concluded that HK's international status will not be undermined, let alone replaced by China's alternatives. Evidence from China's various Free Trade Zone / financial hub initiatives over recent years suggests that none of them seems to jeopardize HK's position.

The reasons for our above conclusion are enumerated succinctly in yesterday's MingPao article "香港打不死" as follows:

“連深交所和上交所也不願做的生意,才放到未來的澳門交易所去掛牌,這些企業的質素和風險水平偏低,應是客觀事實!對香港來說,這些企業的吸引力也應極其有限!從這個角度看,澳門交易所理應不會是港交所的直接競爭對手。”

“香港能夠成為國際金融中心,內地金融界認為主因是背靠祖國、乘着大陸資本市場快速發展而冒起;無可否認,這是一個原因,但更重要的是香港擁有幾個特點,是大陸城市無法「仿效」的,包括法治制度、資金自由進出、資訊自由流通;不用多,光靠這3招,內地城市就無法超越香港。”

In a gist, PRC cities cannot replicate HK's rule of law, free capital movement, free information flow. These are the 3 insurmountable barriers of entry that prevent them from overtaking HK.

2019年12月16日星期一

HK metro rail network – woefully underprovided

Posted on 14th December, 2019 Stand News :

The perception that Hong Kong’s traffic congestion is worsening by the day is no new sentiment to the road users of the city, and one of the most obvious solutions to this problem has been, and will continue to be, the extension and intensification of the metro rail network.

This article explores how HK compares with other global cities in its metro rail provision. But before we start, a quick look at how land use is distributed between the various modes of transportation may already provide an answer to the question: Do we have enough rails already?

Land allocation alludes to rail under-provision

As the chart below illustrates, land used by railway is barely 0.4% of total, compared to 4.2% of land dedicated to roads. For roads to occupy 10x as much land area as rail but only carries 1.6x as many passengers (rail passengers number 5 million, and are 38.5% of total daily trips), HK’s transport policy priorities is clearly misdirected.

Chart 1: Land use of roads is over 10x that of rails in HK

Which city to compare HK to?

Whilst relative land use gives an idea of appropriateness versus other forms of transport, whether the absolute level of rail coverage is right would be best tested against other cities.

When measuring up HK’s railway provision to other global cities, the usual crop of candidates spring to mind, but we believe London may be the most appropriate ‘rival’ given that both cities are international financial centres and global cities, as well as similar populations (HK’s 7.4m vs. London’s 8.6m) and even population density (HK at 6,480 people/km2 vs. London at 5,518 people/km2). What’s more, average salary for Hong Kong (US$2,716/month) and London (US$2,773/month) are also comparable.

In the below analysis, we will compare HK’s rail coverage to London’s, by and large, while making passing comments on other cities where relevant.

Rail length per urban area: HK in the short

The more area a city covers, the more rail would be required to service that area. We therefore start with this measure to compare whether HK is providing sufficient rail footprint; here we use road congestion (high congestion means insufficient rail services) as the second parameter:

Chart 2: Area density in rail length at London levels may cut congestion by 3%

The TomTom congestion level for 2018, defined as the amount of extra travel time spent by drivers across the entire year, suggests that the city is doing relatively well, but with rail density behind London (Chart 2), perhaps improved coverage will lead to lower congestion levels? The correlation here suggests a small improvement of some 3%.

Based on the above correlation, Hong Kong may need to build an additional 46.7 kilometres of metro rails to match London on the route length/km2 measure.

Route length per head – even more increase needed

Another way to measure rail density may be to compare the length of the railway network to the city’s population, as shown in Chart 3 below. Again, increased rail provision to London levels could reduce the city’s traffic congestion overall by 9% or so:

Chart 3: Per capita route length at London levels may cut congestion by 9%

Based on the above correlation, Hong Kong may need to build an additional 127.1 kilometres of metro rails to match London on the route length/head measure.

Best measure – combine area with population: HK still inadequate

Land area and population by themselves may not truly reflect the living density of people in the city, so we combined these to produce Chart 4, which plots route length as measured by each city’s population density:

Chart 4: London level route-population density may cut congestion by 9%

One clear observation is that cities with low railway coverage, such as Bangkok and Mexico City are plagued with very high congestion levels. Although HK is relatively lucky in that regard, we could again improve the rail provision levels to London’s standards. In this case, the reduction in congestion would again be in the 9% region, similar to the length-per-head measure.

Based on the above correlation, Hong Kong may need to build an additional 331.2 kilometres of metro rails to match London on the route length/population density measure. This is the highest of the three approaches employed above. So how much is 331km of rail?

HK needs to double its railway network to get to Beijing/Shanghai levels

To reach London levels, HK needs to build 43% of its existing system length (Chart 5), but this is not the world leading rail advancement known in Tokyo – to be like Tokyo’s route length / population density, HK needs to build two times more of its current network!

Chart 5: Hong Kong to build 331 km more railways to reach London’s level

NB: Hong Kong’s total route length is 231 km as of October 2019

All this goes to show how backward the planning mentality HK’s transport framework is, and how much more remains to be done.

One further perspective to analyse the level of rail provision may be looking at the ridership metrics, as shown below:

Chart 6: Hong Kong to extend the railway by 46% with reference to New York’s level

Again, Sao Paulo is a clear case of under-provision, resulting in ultra-high intensity of use over a short/limited network, while at the same time too few citizens per capita get to enjoy the convenience of metro rails.

On the other extreme, the New York-London-Madrid axis perhaps are the closest to best class rail planning – with more riders per head, but lower number of riders per kilometre of rail. The sardine packing pictures so distinguishing Tokyo and Hong Kong clearly have room for improvement!

If HK was to reach New York level of route length while keeping the same level of ridership/population, some 336.8 km new rails need to be laid here (or 46% of current network capacity). This curiously, is very close to the 43% increase suggested for London using the per-population-density measure.

Let us stop issuing ever more car licences like the HKSAR government has been doing, and start digging some rail tunnels.
  
The author would like to thank Cherry Lui of The University of Hong Kong for assisting in data collection, analysis, and drafting this article.

Sources:

2019年12月9日星期一

Lower US State Tax Drives Population Inflows, Home Price Rises

Posted on 9th December, 2019 Stand News :

We have discussed how Hong Kong’s low tax reputation was increasingly at risk as even large economies have caught up in lowering their top tax brackets in recent years (see HK govt complacency losing out in competitive tax cutting). One of the most aggressive of these being the USA under the pro-business Trump administration.

In this article we explore further how the intra-USA tax competition is panning out and how this may impact property prices in the longer term.

Lower corporate tax leads to more employment

Looking at the current top corporate tax rates amongst the US states, it is possible to reach a conclusion that those states with low tax rates may be enjoying large growths in populations as companies move their activities to these jurisdictions.

In our study in the rest of the article, we will focus on several poster-child states, namely Texas, Delaware, Florida (known for lower taxes), as well as California, New York, and Illinois (famed for more regulations and higher burden for the corporates). These will be coloured orange in subsequent charts.

In low corporate tax states, such as Nevada/Washing/S Dakota (marked green), population growths reached as high as mid teens over the past ten years (2010-2019), compared to the high tax states (marked red) with low single digit growth or even falls (eg Illinois):

Chart 1: low tax leads to population inflows

Individual taxes also impact population movements
Just having lower corporate taxes may not be enough, as take-home pay for the employees will also impact on the desire of people to stay or leave a state. We therefore looked also at tax burden on residents, which measures all state and local taxes, and specifically, property taxes, income taxes, and sales and excise taxes.

The outcome of the study are equally persuasive, with our highlighted low tax states again featuring high population growths (Delaware, Florida, Texas), whilst the high tax burden states New York, alongside Hawaii & Maine seeing anaemic increases over the same decade:

Chart 2: High tax burden (as of 2019) resulted in lower population growth


Changes in tax rates an easy policy tool to spur growth?
So which states have done the most to attract immigration? Delaware and Florida (within our highlight set) seemed to have done the most, and indeed achieved the best results, compared to Hawaii and Louisiana on the other extreme, resulting in minimal growth in the number of residents over a decade:

Chart 3: Tax cuts attract, hikes repel

So here may be the best guide for anyone contemplating moves, be it for jobs, studies, or even retirements, the lowest current state of tax burdens in descending order:

Chart 4 : Tax burden by states 2019 vs National average tax burden 2019

Other personal reasons aside, it seems our highlight states of Delaware and Florida should be on most mover’s consideration list, whilst even those in jobs or studies now may want to think twice fore remaining in places like New Yor and Hawaii?

Immigration – housing demand – home price outperformance
The natural conclusion from the above studies must be that, for property investors, level of taxes would have a bearing on the performance of home prices, and tax cuts should lead to outperformance.

Again, the states with tax cuts over the past decade (eg, Florida) saw some of the best home price increases, whereas Louisiana and Vermont were much more modest in their price action over the same period:

Chart 5: low tax seem to benefit home prices too


So in conclusion, property investing may benefit from buying in accommodative tax jurisdictions and even more in jurisdictions where large reductions in tax burdens are being implemented. This is certainly a lesson for Hong Kong, where our globally competitive low tax advantage has now become almost non-existent, when the power hogging administrators prefer taking the money from the people first and then return little favours in the form of the so called ‘Economic Relief Measures’.

Finally, here is the map view of the US population growth rates, with the names of the states coded in high to low tax change colours:

Chart 6 : high population growth (deep blue) coincides with bigger tax cuts (green texts), and vice versa for lower tax cuts (red texts)

The author would like to thank Christy Leung of City University of Hong Kong for assisting in data collection, analysis, and drafting this article.

2019年12月4日星期三

Singapore, Switzerland leads HK in tech race 金融科技發展滯後 初創企業港為次選?

Hong Kong is well behind in FinTech development versus competitors. Singapore again ranks #1 in the world despite billions of dollars of government-directed initiatives spent by the SAR:

儘管港府在金融科技上大灑金錢,卻在此領域敬陪末座,排名第九,與星加坡(#1)及瑞士(#2,#3)望塵莫及:

 Table: Hong Kong ranked 9th in FinTech Hub Ranking
表:金融科技中心排名中,香港僅排第9

The superiority of Switzerland and Singapore tech incubation also lead the world by the measure of 'startup formation per capita': HK only saw 0.9 startups per 10k population in the past five years, less than half Singapore levels (at 1.9):

由另一個指標:「人均初創企業成立數字」來看,香港更不足新加坡的一半:

 Chart: Singapore leads in start-ups founded per capita
 圖:新加坡人均初創企業成立數字大幅拋離香港

See here, here and here for our previous related articles.